What happens if two stories tie during voting?

Have an impartial third party or a designated judge break the tie, or resolve it with a quick round of rock-paper-scissors between the storytellers.

Can players pass their turn?

Yes, but passing means taking a penalty drink immediately. This ensures players participate or face the consequences.

What kind of stories work best for this game?

Funny, embarrassing, or outrageous stories tend to win the most votes. Avoid overly long or serious anecdotes unless your crowd enjoys those.

What’s the final penalty for the losing team?

The losing team must collectively finish a shared drink, like a pitcher or large cup, while the winners cheer them on.

Best Story Wins - Drinking Game Rules & How to Play

Best Story Wins is a drinking game in the Team Games category for 4-15 players that takes about 15-30 min with a easy difficulty level.

Tell stories, vote on best

Equipment Needed

Team supplies
Drinks

Setup

Divide players into two teams and provide each team with a notepad or phone for jotting down ideas. Place drinks within easy reach of everyone, as penalties and rewards involve drinking throughout the game. Decide the play order by flipping a coin or having a rock-paper-scissors match between team captains.

How to Play Best Story Wins

Set up the game according to basic rules
Players take turns or play simultaneously
Penalties result in drinking
Success means assigning drinks
Continue until winner emerges
Loser faces final penalty
Winner earns bragging rights
Adjust rules as needed for your group

Tips & Strategies

Start your stories with a hook,nothing grabs votes like a shocking or hilarious opening line. Use callbacks or references to inside jokes from earlier in the party, which can make your story feel more relatable and engaging to your audience. If you're assigning drinks as a reward, spread them evenly among the opposing team to keep the game fun and lighthearted. Prepare for the final penalty by having an extra drink ready; losers often dread that last sip after a long game.

Variations

Speed Stories. Truth or Lie. Penalty Voting

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if two stories tie during voting?: Have an impartial third party or a designated judge break the tie, or resolve it with a quick round of rock-paper-scissors between the storytellers.
Can players pass their turn?: Yes, but passing means taking a penalty drink immediately. This ensures players participate or face the consequences.
What kind of stories work best for this game?: Funny, embarrassing, or outrageous stories tend to win the most votes. Avoid overly long or serious anecdotes unless your crowd enjoys those.
What’s the final penalty for the losing team?: The losing team must collectively finish a shared drink, like a pitcher or large cup, while the winners cheer them on.

Players: 4-15 | Duration: 15-30 min | Difficulty: easy

Related Drinking Games

Gauntlet — Sequential drinking challenge gauntlet
Costume Contest — Best costume wins, others drink
Wine Tasting Blind — Blind wine identification
Team Trivia Drinking — Team trivia with drinking penalties
Cooking Challenge — Cook dishes, judged with drinks
Guess the Drawing — Quick drawing guessing game
Spelling Bee Teams — Team spelling competition
Wisest Wizard Tournament — Team wizard staff building competition

From Our Blog

Outdoor Drinking Games for Your Next Bash — When the sun's shining and the vibe's just right, there's no better way to enjoy it than with some outdoor drinking games. I’ve hosted more than my fair share of backyard shindigs, rooftop ragers, and...
Weekend Party Ideas to Amp Up Your Get-Together — If you're looking to host an unforgettable weekend party, it's all about the games. Sure, you could just throw on some music and let everyone mingle, but where's the flair in that? Adding some engagin...
Weekend Party Ideas That Bring the Fun — So, you're planning a weekend bash and want to make sure it's one for the books. Whether it's a casual barbecue with friends, a rooftop gathering, or just a chill night in with your closest crew, havi...

Browse more Team Games drinking games or see all drinking games.